Jonathan and the oil
spill
Jonathan (our
client’s name has been changed) was cycling to work when his bike shot out from
under him as he ran over a patch of oil on the roadway. He suffered a serious fracture of his right
femur. Fortunately, other road users
were able not only to attend to him but to see the presence of oil on the
highway.
There was no obvious
culprit, but one witness suggested it might be a council rubbish lorry exuding
spillage as it proceeded on its collection.
In these cases it is important to try to identify the defendant so that
the claim can be made against that driver’s insurers. If a defendant cannot be identified, a claim
is made against the Motor Insurers Bureau under the “Untraced Drivers’
Agreement”. Under this agreement, the
MIB will pick up liability for injuries caused by drivers who cannot be
traced. In the case of a spillage on the
floor, they have to be satisfied that the spillage was identifiable and posed a
risk. In this case, not only did the
emergency services attend and confirm the presence of oil on the floor, but
they were able to report it to the council, who sent out a cleaning team to
remove it. So the MIB were not able to
deny liability to compensate.
In the event,
Jonathan recovered £32,000 damages together with the MIB fixed costs under the
Untraced Drivers’ Agreement. These fixed
costs are subject to a maximum of £3,000 and VAT and inevitably leave a
shortfall which has to be paid from the claimant’s compensation.
Jonathan’s
compensation was paid into a Personal Injury Trust to preserve his entitlement
to means tested benefits. It is vitally
important that if an accident victim is getting means tested benefits, they do
not deprive themselves of those benefits by receiving a large lump sum of money
that will bring them over the threshold for benefits entitlement.